The opinions expressed herein are my personal opinions and in no way represent the US Military.
In recent days I have read and watched coverage of the Virginia Tech shooting that continues to question the law enforcement response. They insinuate or just come out and say that people died because of a poor law enforcement response. With nine years of law enforcement experience, five of those years as a trainer, and fifteen years in the military; I have some authority to speak on this issue.
First, take a look at the facts. The first shooting occurs at 7:15 am inside of a dormitory on campus and the suspect leaves the scene. As most shootings are in the early stages, the scene is chaotic, and it is unclear exactly what happened. Within an hour and fifteen minutes a person of interest has been detained and administration officials are meeting to discuss the best course of action (remember, VTech is a school with over 26,000 students, of which 17,000 are commuters). At 9:00 am the administration officials receive their first update from the Campus Police Chief. By 9:26 enough information has developed that an email is sent to the student body and faculty telling them of the shooting and inferring that the suspect is at large and has left the area.
Just prior to 9:45 everyone involved in this investigation believes that the suspect has left the area; something that is very predictable in the given situation. The killer’s video he sent to NBC later confirms the fact that he had in fact left the area after the first shooting.
At 9:45 all hell broke loose. The shooter had returned and had chained the doors shut on Norris Hall, a half mile away from the original shooting; and was up on the second floor moving classroom to classroom shooting everything in his path. Less than seven minutes after it started, it is all over. The shooter has ended his own life upon hearing law enforcement closing on his location. He had plenty of ammunition left, and plenty of victims locked in the building; however, law enforcement’s quick response had left him with no time.
When you look at what law enforcement did, it is really quite incredible. They arrived on scene and organized themselves within the first five minutes. Within the next minute, officers were able to breach doors that had been chained shut and begin making their way to the area the gunshots were coming from. While their guns didn’t fire the fatal shot; their actions certainly saved lives, possibly hundreds of lives. To put it in perspective; most of the critics would still be outside Norris Hall trying to figure out how to open the chained shut doors.
The bottom line is the only thing that could have prevented this tragedy was a full blooded sheepdog in one of those classrooms. There were heroes no doubt, and there were partial sheepdogs, but no full blooded ones could be found. For those not familiar with LTC (retired) Dave Grossman’s essay, “On Sheep, Wolves and Sheepdogs,” take a minute to read it here. You can read more about this here, here, or here from my good friend Righty in a Lefty State.
While many want to blame the gun instead of the shooter, this too is absurd. Even in countries that outlaw all firearms, criminals still have guns. Criminals will always have guns, and the solution is to allow law abiding citizens to have guns in a concealed, responsible manner. One professor with a weapon could have changed everything; or even, God forbid one student with a concealed weapon.
While we mourn the deaths of these thirty-two college students; I can’t help but think of the nearly 100 college age Soldiers and Marines that have already died in Iraq and Afghanistan this month. No flags flown at half staff for these heroes, and no Army memorabilia worn on the suits of those participating in the NFL draft today; the suffering of our military families continues.


